Peanut Butter Fudge Buttercream Cookie

A soft, salty peanut butter cookie topped with a thick swirl of rich chocolate buttercream. A sweet-and-salty duo that never misses.

Why We Love It
This cookie is my chocolate-peanut-butter daydream come to life. Inspired by my all-time favorite candy combo, it’s soft, gooey, fudgy, and just the right amount of salty-sweet. And if you ask me, the holiday shapes, eggs in spring, pumpkins in fall, are hands-down the superior way to eat chocolate peanut butter candy (sorry, original cup). While we don’t bake with those candies here, I can’t help but think of them every time I take a bite of this cookie. Consider this the cookie version of my favorite holiday tradition: rich, nostalgic, and impossible to stop at just one.

Description

A soft, salty peanut butter cookie topped with a thick swirl of rich chocolate buttercream. A sweet-and-salty duo that never misses.

Why We Love It

This cookie is my chocolate-peanut-butter daydream come to life. Inspired by my all-time favorite candy combo, it’s soft, gooey, fudgy, and just the right amount of salty-sweet. And if you ask me, the holiday shapes, eggs in spring, pumpkins in fall, are hands-down the superior way to eat chocolate peanut butter candy (sorry, original cup). While we don’t bake with those candies here, I can’t help but think of them every time I take a bite of this cookie. Consider this the cookie version of my favorite holiday tradition: rich, nostalgic, and impossible to stop at just one.

Shop Now